MI > Otsego > Gaylord > 7441 First Court Avenue
  • 7 Bedrooms
  • 3 Full Bath
  • 1 Half Bath
  • 5,086 SqFt
  • MLS# 1930695
Contact Customer Care

Mon-Fri 9am-9pm Sat/Sun 9am-7pm

800-871-9992

Contact Customer Care

Mon-Fri 9am-9pm Sat/Sun 9am-7pm

248-208-3883

By proceeding, you consent to receive calls, emails, and texts from Real Estate One and others about your inquiry and other home-related matters, but not as a condition of any purchase. To opt-out, you can reply 'stop' to texts or click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Msg/data rates may apply. View Privacy Policy.
Step back in time with this extraordinary turn-of-the-century gem, originally the first courthouse of Otsego County. This historic property, rich in heritage and charm, is now available for the first time in years--a rare opportunity to bring your vision to life. Once serving as Otsego County's original seat and courthouse, this remarkable building later became Reid's Inn, then the Poplar Inn, and most recently, the Otsego Lake Inn. Today, it stands as a private home, beloved for hosting reunions, receptions, and intimate gatherings. Boasting seven bedrooms several of which have access to the second floor enclosed sleeping porch, and four well-appointed bathrooms. This expansive home also features a grand game room known as the Saloon, a formal dining room that comfortably seats 16, and a stately reception parlor. The kitchen, complete with a pantry, is designed for hosting in style, while the multiple porches and verandas invite you to relax and soak in the surroundings. The outdoor space is equally enchanting, with a full-sized hot tub perfect for stargazing and viewing the northern lights, as well as an outdoor shower area. Located just three blocks from the picturesque Otsego State Park, this property is ideally situated near the Iron-Belle biking trail and the main Otsego snowmobile trail, making it a haven for outdoor enthusiasts. In the warmer months, explore the Golf Mecca with over thirty courses nearby, and in winter, enjoy the area's premier skiing--both downhill and cross-country--where Mother Nature provides the best snow in the lower peninsula. This remarkable home, sitting on just under half an acre, includes an additional 1.23-acre wooded parcel, offering even more potential for expansion or privacy. Zoned R-2, the property provides a myriad of possibilities for future use. Some furniture and antiques may be included in the sale, allowing you to preserve the historic charm and character that defines this unbelievable offering.

Property Information

Status
Active 
Address
7441 First Court Avenue 
City
Gaylord 
Zip
49735 
County
Otsego 
Township
Otsego Lake 
Possession
Negotiable 
Zoning
Commercial, Residential
Property Type
Residential
Listing Date
02/06/2025 
List Price
$599,900
Total Finished SqFt
5,086 
Above Grade SqFt
5,086 
Unfinished SqFt
1,015 
Garage Desc.
None 
Waterfront Desc
All Sports, Inland Lake, Near Pub.Access w/in 500' 
Water
Private Well
Sewer
Private Septic
Year Built
1874 
Home Style
2 Story, Bed & Breakfast, Colonial, Lodge 

School Information

School District
Gaylord 

Taxes

Taxes
$1,373 
Summer Taxes
$651 
Winter Taxes
$722 

Rooms and Land

PrimaryBedroom
10X12 2nd Floor
Bedroom2
14X16 2nd Floor
Bedroom3
10X12 2nd Floor
Bedroom4
10X10 2nd Floor
Dining
18X16 1st Floor
Family
38X20 1st Floor
Kitchen
35X16.5 1st Floor
Laundry
10X6 1st Floor
Living
33X25 1st Floor
Other
8X20 1st Floor
Basement
Full, Michigan Basement 
Cooling
Forced Air, Natural Gas 
Heating
Forced Air, Natural Gas 
Acreage
1.7 
Lot Dimensions
157x130 
Appliances
Dryer, Hot Tub, Natural Gas Water Heater, Oven/Range, Refrigerator, Washer 

Features

Fireplace Desc.
Fireplace(s), Wood 
Interior Features
Built-In Bookcase, Den/Study, Drywall, Formal Dining Room, Foyer Entrance, Mud Room, Pantry 
Exterior Materials
Wood 
Exterior Features
Countryside View, Covered Porch, Garden Area, Landscaped, Patio, Porch, Seasonal View, Sidewalk 
Additional Buildings
Garden/Storage Shed 

Frequently Asked Questions

Mortgage Calculator

years
annual
annual

Get Pre-Approved

  • Market Statistics
  • Property History
  • Schools Information
  • Local Business
Market Statistics
Property History
MLS Number New Status Previous Status Activity Date New List Price Previous List Price Sold Price DOM
1930695 Active Feb 6 2025 4:46PM $599,900 40
1926936 Expired Active Jan 31 2025 2:16AM 145
1926936 Nov 9 2024 3:15PM $599,900 $649,900 145
1926936 Active Sep 8 2024 9:57PM $649,900 145
1917024 Withdrawn Active Jan 11 2024 9:16AM 80
472326 Nov 15 2023 8:45PM $674,500 $699,500 106
1917024 Nov 15 2023 8:27PM $674,500 $699,500 80
1917024 Nov 3 2023 12:16PM $699,500 $749,500 80
472326 Nov 3 2023 12:15PM $699,500 $749,500 106
1917024 Active Oct 24 2023 12:29PM $749,500 80
472326 Oct 19 2023 3:15PM $749,500 $799,500 106
472326 Active Sep 27 2023 5:15PM $799,500 106
School Information
Local Business

Learn More About This Listing

Contact Customer Care

Mon-Fri 9am-9pm Sat/Sun 9am-7pm

800-871-9992

Contact Customer Care

Mon-Fri 9am-9pm Sat/Sun 9am-7pm

248-208-3883

By proceeding, you consent to receive calls, emails, and texts from Real Estate One and others about your inquiry and other home-related matters, but not as a condition of any purchase. To opt-out, you can reply 'stop' to texts or click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Msg/data rates may apply. View Privacy Policy.

Listing Broker

MITAAR Logo

Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Northern Michi
Office Address 830 E. Front St, Suite 110

7441 First Court Avenue Gaylord
Contact us
$599,900
For Sale • Bed: 7 • Bath: 3/1